Reddit’s 5 Best Pillows Are Amazing

Young woman hugging pillow on comfortable bed with silky linens

Reddit’s 5 Best Pillows Are Amazing

Key Points

  • Reddit is a popular platform for recommendations because it offers authentic reviews from real people.
  • The Tempur-Pedic Symphony memory foam pillow is highly recommended for its firmness and durability.
  • The Purple Harmony Pillow, made of latex, provides excellent neck support and breathability.
  • The ComfyComfy Organic Buckwheat Pillow is surprisingly comfortable and moldable, with the added benefit of being organic and sustainable.
  • The Coop Home Goods Eden Bed Pillow is adjustable and customizable, making it perfect for those who struggle to find the right size and shape.
  • The Core Products Tri-Core Cervical Support Pillow is designed specifically for neck support and alignment, with options for firmness and size.

With most people these days living fairly hectic lives, it’s no wonder the majority of us don’t get as much quality sleep as we should. Even when we are paying attention to our health, our sleep often gets ignored. Although getting enough hours of shut-eye is important, the quality of our sleep is just as crucial. If you’ve ever woken up with neck and back pain and a persistent headache, you know the problems that an uncomfortable duvet or pillow can cause. Sometimes, you can fix this by adjusting your sleep position. But a lot of the time, the only solution is to swap out your pillows. To this end, we’re going to dive into the very best pillows, as recommended by Reddit. The goal here is to get you the blissful rest that you deserve.

Why Is Reddit So Popular for Recommendations?

It may seem like an unlikely place to go for advice, but there’s some good logic behind it. In this digital age, information is spreading faster than ever. Unfortunately, that also means misinformation is more prevalent than it has been in the past. While many companies have good intentions, some are out there just trying to make a quick buck. The average consumer has also become more wary of what companies say, especially online, and is aware of the possibility of reviews being faked. While Reddit isn’t a magic bullet in this regard, there’s a sense of increased authenticity that’s lacking on some other platforms.

Many people turn to Reddit for the honest (sometimes brutally so) reviews that can be found there, from real people and real customers. Not only for consumer products, but for everything from podcasts and movies to video games and even anime. It’s always a smart idea to get feedback from people who have tried a lot of products out themselves. This way, you can see how they stack up in reality. This is especially important when you’re on the lookout for new pillows. There are a mind-boggling number of different kinds to choose from. Every pillow type has its own strengths and weaknesses, and every person’s body responds differently. Personal preference, weight distribution, and health conditions all play a huge part in deciding which pillow is right for you.

One of the best ways to make the best decision for your needs is to consult people who have personal experience with these products. Without further ado, let’s get into the best pillows as recommended by Reddit. Many of these are from the r/BuyitForLife subreddit, so you can be sure they are suggested with longevity in mind.

Tempur-Pedic Memory Foam Symphony Pillow

Premium Memory Foam Comfort
Tempur-Pedic Memory Foam Symphony Pillow
  • Dual-sided for back and side sleepers
  • Lasts a long time with proper care
  • Hypoallergenic and machine washable cover
  • Never loses its shape
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/10/2023 01:09 am GMT

If you spend any time on Reddit or the internet in general, for that matter, one of the most common names to pop up is the Tempur-Pedic Symphony memory foam pillow. While the price can be a bit steep compared to the average pillow, once people convert to these, they tend to become long-term fans. The memory foam filling provides a lovely firmness without being too firm. The foam effortlessly molds to the contours of your head and neck before returning to its original shape the next day. This pillow’s sturdiness isn’t to be underestimated. Many buyers have said that they’ve had their Tempur-Pedic pillows for a long time, even over a decade, and there are no signs of wear and tear. Considering you could end up replacing a cheap pillow every few years, this definitely sounds like a sensible investment.

As a bonus, the cover is hypoallergenic and machine washable. You can rest assured knowing you’ll not have to deal with any dust mites or unpleasant allergens. While this pillow is great for most people, it might not be supportive enough if you have significant neck problems. But all in all, as an all-around pillow, the Tempur-Pedic is hard to beat.

Purple Harmony Pillow

Ideal for Side Sleepers
Purple Harmony Pillow
  • Great for side sleepers
  • Never deforms or loses shape
  • Removes moisture and stays cool all night long
  • Firm and supportive
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/10/2023 01:09 am GMT

Another great option is made from a material that might surprise you: latex! Apparently good for a lot more things than a Jane Fonda-style workout, a latex pillow can offer a combination of neck support and breathability that is always as good as the first night. Virtually every user has commented positively on its effectiveness at wicking away moisture and remaining pleasantly cool through the night. As there’s no stuffing or down feathers involved, this pillow is sure to last for a while and not degrade over time. The latex is also food-grade and hypoallergenic, so you don’t need to worry about any nasty reactions. This is a great choice for the majority of people, but side sleepers in particular seem to love the support the Purple pillow gives.

ComfyComfy Organic Buckwheat Pillow

Cool and Sustainable
ComfyComfy Organic Luxury Buckwheat Pillow
  • Organic and sustainable materials
  • Molds to support your neck and back
  • Filters heat and moisture
  • Customizable fill
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/10/2023 01:09 am GMT

Keeping with the theme of unexpected pillow materials, we’ve arrived at pillows made of buckwheat. We know you’re probably thinking that doesn’t sound very comfortable to lie on. But apparently, that couldn’t be further from the truth. While buckwheat isn’t the softest of materials, only the husks are used here. So, it’s a lot more moldable and forgiving than you may think. While the husks don’t last forever, you can get many years of use out of them. As long as you periodically sun-dry the pillows to prevent mold from occurring, this pillow will last a long while. If treated right, you can expect to get many years of use.

Some users do report that the pillows make an audible noise as the husks move around. If you’re a very light sleeper, this may not work for you. But most people don’t seem to find it too bothersome. Buckwheat also doesn’t retain heat very well. This will either be a bonus or a drawback depending on whether you’re a hot or cold sleeper. Overall, this is an excellent option if you want neck support, tend to be warm in bed, and like the idea of an organic and sustainable pillow material.

Coop Home Goods Eden Bed Pillow 

Adjustable Foam Blend
Coop Home Goods Eden Bed Pillow Queen Size
  • Can add or remove filling as desired for the perfect loft
  • Great balance of firmness and softness
  • Machine washable
  • Extra fill included
  • CertiPUR-US and GREENGUARD Gold certified
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/08/2023 08:52 pm GMT

If you’re a fan of a memory foam pillow but struggle to find one that’s the exact right size and shape, you’re in luck. The Eden pillow from Coop has a unique blend of microfiber and memory foam that is designed to be adjustable. You can access the filling inside and add or remove the material to suit your own needs. You even get a bag of extra fill included with your order, so you can perfect your sleeping arrangement after testing out the pillow. We always love a supportive pillow that’s also washable, and that’s exactly what you’re getting here. The fact that you can customize the filling to your own liking is an excellent way to achieve new levels of comfort you previously thought impossible, and much appreciated by Redditors. If you find traditional memory foam a little too firm, this is a great choice.

 Core Products Tri-Core Cervical Support Pillow 

Unparalelled Neck Support
Core Products Tri-Core Cervical Support Pillow for Neck Pain, Standard Firm
  • The best choice to eliminate neck problems
  • Provides support while realigning neck and spine
  • Variety of sizes and firmness options available to suit all preferences
  • Hypoallergenic
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
12/10/2023 01:14 am GMT

While all the pillows we’ve found provided a good amount of neck support, if this is a major priority for you, you’ll love this cervical pillow from Core Products. Memory foam pillows work wonders for a lot of people. However, a cervical pillow designed for this purpose is rated premium in neck support. The contoured design of the pillow ensures that your head is cradled, protected and realigned with your neck, which is supported on either side by the raised edges. There are also the “gentle” and “firm” options to choose from, as well as three sizes, which is a nice touch.

You may have to test to see if the firm option is too much for your neck. But it’s great that there’s something for all preferences. If you go with this option, it’s important to note that you can overdo it at first. Therefore, it’s best to introduce the cervical pillow into your nighttime routine gradually as your body adjusts.

Reddit’s Best Pillows: Wrapping Up

Choosing the best pillow isn’t the easiest of tasks. But turning to user recommendations is a great way to find out what your options are. Whether you’re after a supportive or breathable, soft or firm pillow, the right choice is your ticket to a great night’s sleep. All the pillows we’ve mentioned here are hypoallergenic. However, if allergies are an issue for you, just be sure to avoid feather or down-filled pillows. If you want organic and natural materials, a buckwheat pillow may be the solution you’re looking for. In terms of neck support, the benefits of a cervical pillow can’t be understated. Alternatively, if you prioritize a moisture-free pillow that you don’t have to re-fluff all the time, a latex or memory foam pillow is the one for you.

Summary Table

Tempur-Pedic Memory Foam Symphony PillowA memory foam pillow that molds to the contours of your head and neck. It is hypoallergenic and machine washable.
Purple Harmony PillowMade from latex, this pillow offers neck support and breathability. It is also hypoallergenic.
ComfyComfy Organic Buckwheat PillowThis pillow is made from buckwheat husks, providing moldability and support. It is organic and sustainable.
Coop Home Goods Eden Bed PillowA blend of microfiber and memory foam, this pillow is adjustable to suit individual needs. It is also washable.
Core Products Tri-Core Cervical Support PillowDesigned specifically for neck support, this cervical pillow has a contoured design. It comes in three sizes and two firmness options.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why use Reddit for product recommendations?

Reddit is often called the front page of the internet, as it’s many people’s first stop to comment on their experiences, review products, and ask others for their opinions. While the information isn’t guaranteed to be foolproof, it’s a good place to get honest advice about a purchase you’re considering, as the contributors tend to give very detailed reviews.

Can I use any of the pillows suggested on Reddit?

While many of the recommended pillows are excellent quality options, they’re not all appropriate for everyone. Some pillows are more breathable than others, while others are firmer or hypoallergenic. It really depends on how you tend to sleep, how hot you are, if you have any neck or back issues to manage, and of course, your budget. Many of the suggested pillows can last a very long time, however, so are worth the investment.

What pillows are best for neck problems?

Generally, a cervical pillow is what you need if you have significant issues with your neck. These provide neck support and lower the angle of your head so that your neck and spine are comfortably aligned while you sleep.

Are there any budget-friendly pillow recommendations from Reddit?

Some of the suggested pillows do command a relatively high cost, but there is a lot of variation in prices. More affordable options include the Tempur-Pedic Symphony pillow, which is a great all-round pillow, and the Core Products Tri-Core Cervical Support Pillow, which is great for those with neck issues.

Are there any pillows made of natural materials?

Yes, a buckwheat pillow is organic, natural, and sustainable, and provides a surprisingly comfortable sleep. However, all the pillows here are hypoallergenic, so you can be sure you won’t be in contact with any unhealthy materials.

How do I find what I need on Reddit?

You can simply search for your desired topic in the search bar at the top of the homepage, or look for a particular subreddit. These are essentially forums, or collections of discussions about a related topic, where people give advice and their personal experiences. Within these communities, you can search for keywords related to what you want to find out. For example, if you need even more pillow recommendations or information, type “pillow” into the Reddit search bar.

To top