© metamorworks / Shutterstock.com

Wireless signals can be affected by various barriers such as concrete walls, wooden doors, large spaces, equipment interference, and glass, depending on the distance between the transmitter and receiver device. To overcome this signal degradation, there are two solutions available.

One option is to use a high-end wireless router with multiple antennas. However, these routers can be expensive and may not always provide coverage to the entire area. An alternative solution is to use a mesh Wi-Fi or a repeater, which effectively extend the wireless signal in a home, office, or any other location. As a result, mesh Wi-Fi or repeaters are a more popular choice among people.

In today’s article, we’re diving into the differences between mesh Wi-Fi and repeaters. We’ll discuss all the differences in each technology, so you can get a feel for what works best.

Mesh Wi-Fi vs. Repeaters: Side-by-Side Comparison

Mesh Wi-Fi Wireless Repeater
What isa Network of wireless devices that communicate with one another without relying on a router or access pointA device that retransmits the signal from a centralized router
Technology typeWirelessWireless
Works on IEEE standard802.11s802.11
Potential UseCovers the entire premises by rebroadcasting the signal using wireless mesh devices and a router.Enhance the signal produced by a centralized device such as a router or access point.
Developed in20102000
Frequency bands2.4 GHz, 5GHz2.4 GHz, 5 GHz
Band AvailabilityTribandSingle, Dual bands
BandwidthHigherlower
ConnectivityEasily sync with devicesThe user needs to roam around
Coverage areaIdeal for factories, multi-story buildings, corporate offices, seaports, etc.Best for small homes, offices, gaming arenas, etc.
Hardware requirementMesh routers and other mesh devicesAccess points or Wifi router 
Supporting devicesLaptops, Mobile phones, tablets, gaming consoles, TVs, etc.PCs, laptops, smartphones, etc.
Power requirementHigherLower
SecurityHighLow
SetupEasyDifficult
Number of ConnectionsManyFew
ScalabilityHighly scale-ableNot very scale-able due to interference
PriceHigh ($180 to $550)Low ($45 to $100)

Mesh Wi-Fi vs. Repeaters: What’s the Difference?

A Wireless repeater is a device that extends the signal from a router or access point. These repeaters rebroadcast the signal to every corner of the premises, including dead zones. And a mesh Wi-Fi network helps propagate the signal within the premises without the assistance of any centralized device.

Usually, you need to deploy multiple mesh devices that communicate with one another to transmit signals in every corner of your home, providing better connectivity, increased speed, low latency, and preventing dead zones.

A Wi-Fi mesh is a network of wireless devices that communicate with one another without relying on a single device such as a router or access point. In this network, wireless devices, known as nodes, communicate with one another in a peer-to-peer fashion, providing seamless connectivity, increasing network speed, lowering latency, and eliminating dead zones.

They are ideal for covering large areas where signal interruption or interference occurs, and cable laying is impossible, such as a large mall, factory, or multi-story building.

A Wireless repeater/ Wi-Fi repeater is a short-range device that extends and strengthens Wi-Fi signals from a router within the home, office, or other small premises. Although these devices are simple to set up and use little power, they sometimes reduce bandwidth, cause interference, slow down your internet connection, and do not support scalability.

Here are more specifics on their differences.

Coverage area 

When we compare the coverage areas of both technologies, we can easily conclude that Wi-Fi mesh is the clear winner. A typical Wi-Fi mesh network’s coverage area is 2000 to 5000 square feet, which we can expand by adding new Wi-Fi mesh devices. You can also expand or change the coverage area.

On the other hand, a Wi-Fi repeater is a short-range device that can help you cover smaller areas such as homes, offices, or shops. They can increase the signal range from 200 to 2000 square feet. 

Network scalability 

People often choose wireless connectivity because it allows them to access the internet without the limitation of cables or wires. But, sometimes, wireless networks have limitations, especially with how far your device can get from the transmitter.

Unfortunately, if you can’t extend the signal range, this great convenience becomes a burden. But you can use devices such as a Booster, Wi-Fi mesh, or repeater to scale your in-house wireless networks.

Note that the scalability of both technologies differs, with Wi-Fi mesh providing greater range and connectivity. Repeaters are less effective because they require many signal-extending devices, which frequently interfere with one another, and sometimes defeat the purpose.

Flexibility

Flexibility is an essential factor to keep in mind when choosing wireless network extensions because there may be times when you need to cover dead zones within your premises. A dead zone is an area within a wireless LAN location where Wi-Fi does not work, primarily due to radio interference or range issues.

A Wi-Fi mesh network works excellently in such a case because it has a simple procedure for adding or removing a wireless mesh router or device. This makes it more practical for covering a large area, a multi-story building, or even a shopping mall.

When it comes to Wi-Fi repeaters, while they can extend the wireless signal, they are not as adaptable as Wi-Fi mesh. This is because every time you add a repeater to your network, you increase the chances of interference and broadcast storms, which can eventually reduce data rates or cause a network blackout. To address this issue, Wi-Fi repeaters use a separate SSID, which only reduces interference to a limited extent.

Data rates

When browsing the internet via Wi-Fi, the maximum data rate is required, but if you do not get the desired results, the situation becomes quite frustrating. This is why selecting the appropriate technology is critical. Comparing the data rates of both technologies, we can conclude that Wi-Fi mesh is far better than implementing a Wi-Fi repeater in your network.

Best Routers Under $500
A wireless repeater takes an existing signal from a wireless router or wireless access point and rebroadcasts it to create a second network. 

©sdecoret/Shutterstock.com

This is because a Wi-Fi mesh creates a single network with the help of multiple mesh devices that do not interfere with each other and hand off the connection at the most vital point, allowing the user to get consistent data rates even when roaming around the premises. But, if you extend your network with a Wi-Fi repeater, you cannot expect the same data rate throughout the premises because these devices cause interference.

Reliability   

When working with wireless devices, network node reliability is critical; otherwise, you will experience intermittent outages, lower data rates, or even a complete blackout.

Wi-Fi mesh networks are ideal for this application because they are comprised of multiple mesh nodes that are not dependent on a centralized router or any other device. Hence, there is no single point of failure due to its peer-to-peer nature. If a network node fails, it does not affect the entire network.

Wi-Fi repeaters cannot provide this level of reliability because they broadcast the signal of an access point or router. The entire network will darken if their connection with the centralized device fails.

Ease of use   

Due to their uniformity, Wi-Fi mesh networks are simple to implement. You can set them up in 15 minutes without fearing interference or causing a blackout due to a network node failure.

On the other hand, Wi-Fi repeaters are more challenging to configure and take longer to set up than Wi-Fi mesh because you must create a new network with a different SSID each time to reduce interference.

Cost 

Wi-Fi repeaters have nailed the Wi-Fi mesh in this category, as the average cost of a Wi-Fi repeater can range from $45 to $100. At the same time, the Wi-Fi mesh requires more peripherals, ranging in price from $180 to $550.

Mesh Wi-Fi vs. Repeaters: 10 Must-Know Facts

  1. Wi-Fi mesh and Wi-Fi repeaters both extend and amplify wireless signals.
  2. Wi-Fi mesh supports multiple wireless bands, one of which is 2.4 Ghz and the other is 5 GHz.
  3. Wi-Fi repeaters are available in single and dual-band configurations.
  4. Wi-Fi mesh creates a network with a peer-to-peer topology and no single point of failure, whereas repeaters rely solely on a wireless access point or router.
  5. Repeaters are ideal for small homes and offices.
  6. Wi-Fi mesh networks are ideal for use in factories, shopping malls, multi-story buildings, and large homes.
  7. Wi-Fi mesh consumes a lot of energy, while repeaters are energy-efficient.
  8. Wi-Fi repeaters and mesh are designed to improve wireless signal strength and eliminate dead zones, but Wi-Fi Mesh is more effective
  9. Repeaters are challenging to set up because of the multiple SSIDs.
  10. Wi-Fi mesh devices cost more than Wi-Fi repeaters. 

Mesh Wi-Fi vs. Repeaters: Which One Is Better?

Wi-Fi repeaters were developed by the Wi-Fi Alliance to strengthen and eliminate dead zones. While this technology does its best to keep users’ trust, with the advancement of technology and the changing needs of today’s users, it is now only useful in homes or small offices. These repeaters have short ranges of up to 2000 square feet and are highly susceptible to interference.

But since wireless meshes can cover a large area without signal interference, higher latency, or slow speeds, they can quickly meet today’s expanding demands. As a result, a Wi-Fi mesh network is ideal for online gaming, streaming, and downloading content from torrents.

To conclude, wireless networks are now standard household technology, and while they are very convenient to use, there may be times when you are unable to connect to them. This is why you need a repeater or a Wi-Fi mesh to help boost the Wi-Fi signal.

Your requirement determines which technology you use in such circumstances, as both options have pros and cons. So, if you have a large area to cover, we recommend a Wireless mesh, and if you want to boost the signal within your home, a repeater will suffice in addressing all of your signal-related issues.

Mesh Wi-Fi vs. Repeaters: What’s the Difference? FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) 

Is Wi-Fi Mesh similar to a Wi-Fi Repeater?

Wi-Fi mesh is an entire network of multiple wireless devices connected peer-to-peer. This means that no single point of failure exists. While Wi-Fi repeaters are intended for short-range connectivity, they rely heavily on a centralized authority such as a router or an access point.

Does a Wi-Fi Repeater cover a larger area than a Wi-Fi Mesh?

That is incorrect; Wi-Fi repeaters can only cover small areas such as homes and offices. Their typical size ranges from 200 to 2000 square feet. Wi-Fi mesh can cover an area of 2000 to 5000 square feet, which is twice the range of a Wi-Fi repeater.

In what situations can a Wi-Fi mesh or Repeater help?

Wi-Fi mesh and Wi-Fi repeaters help to extend and strengthen wireless signals. We can use them to cover large areas where Ethernet cabling is not an option.

Can Wi-Fi mesh help increase internet speed?

No, Wi-Fi mesh has nothing to do with internet speed. You simply use it to strengthen wireless signals, cover a larger area, and eliminate dead zones.

Is there a benefit to using a Wi-Fi repeater over a Wi-Fi mesh network?

Wi-Fi repeaters and Wi-Fi meshes have advantages that depend solely on our specific needs. However, repeaters are more energy efficient, suitable for small areas, and, most importantly, cheaper.

About the Author

Follow Me On:

LinkedIn Logo

More from History-Computer

  • Wikipedia Available here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wireless_mesh_network#:~:text=Several%20manufacturers%20of%20Wi-Fi%20routers%20began%20offering%20mesh,mesh%20network%2C%20with%20wireless%20links%20between%20adjacent%20satellites.
  • Netgear Available here: https://www.netgear.com/home/discover/wifi-extender-vs-mesh-wifi/
  • PC Mag Available here: https://www.pcmag.com/how-to/wi-fi-range-extender-vs-mesh-network-whats-the-difference
  • Hitron Tech Available here: https://us.hitrontech.com/learn/mesh-wi-fi-vs-wi-fi-repeater-which-is-better-and-why/
  • TP Link Available here: https://www.tp-link.com/us/mesh-wifi/
  • Electronics Notes Available here: https://www.electronics-notes.com/articles/connectivity/wifi-ieee-802-11/wifi-booster-range-extender-repeater.php
  • WaveForm Available here: https://www.waveform.com/pages/wifi-booster-repeater-extender-differences
  • EPB Available here: https://epb.com/get-connected/gig-internet/what-is-a-wi-fi-repeater/