In the early days of computers, tasks and activities were limited exclusively to text. But, as computers and technology became more advanced throughout the 1980s and 1990s, images came into play. Today, we have a whole slew of image file formats to choose from.
But what sets them all apart? Take the JPEG vs TIFF, for example. What’s the difference between these two file formats? How do they compare and contrast with one another? And what’s the ideal usage for each? Let’s discuss this JPEG vs TIFF debate at length below.
JPEG vs TIFF: Side-by-Side Comparison
|Extensions||.jpg, .jpeg, .jpe, .jif, .jfif, .jfi||.tiff, .tif|
|Stands For||Joint Photographic Experts Group||Tag Image File Format|
|Maximum Size||65,535p x 65,535p||4 GB|
|Developers||Joint Photographic Experts Group, IBM, Mitsubishi Electric, AT&T, Canon Inc.||Aldus Corporation (Adobe)|
|First Released||September 18th, 1992||September 12, 1986|
|Purpose||Image compression||Raster graphics storage|
|Lossy or Lossless?||Lossy||Lossless|
|Successor||JPEG 2000||Exif, DCF|
JPEG vs TIFF: What’s the Difference?
While there are plenty of nuances that exist between the JPEG vs TIFF file formats, there are three main distinctions we can make between the two. These are their differences in use, their differences in development, and their differences in image quality.
Firstly, there is what is probably the most apparent difference between JPEG vs TIFF: the difference in usage. JPEGs are intended and reserved for lossy image compression. This helps shrink the size of the image and its metadata without resulting in any noticeable lack of quality when sharing or receiving the images.
TIFFs, on the other hand, are intended for use in storing and sharing raster graphics. These make them ideal for those in the industries of photography, graphic design, print layout, and so on.
Secondly, there’s a difference in development between JPEG vs TIFF. The Joint Photographic Experts Group standardized and published the JPEG’s image compression algorithm back in 1992. The TIFF, on the other hand, was created and popularized by the Aldus Corporation — which we know now as Adobe.
The JPEG was developed for use in sending and receiving images over the computer, whereas the TIFF was developed to store raster graphics for editing and publishing images on the computer.
Thirdly, there’s overall image quality to consider between JPEG vs TIFF. This image quality debate manifests itself in the fact that JPEGs are lossy and TIFF files are lossless. In other words, JPEG files are compressed by their very nature.
Through the compression algorithm, JPEGs have unnecessary or inconspicuous aspects of the image and its metadata is deleted to shrink the image size. TIFF files, by comparison, maintain their image quality and size to remain the best possible version of the image. Think of it like this: The TIFF is the original, and the JPEG is the miniature model.
5 Must-Know Facts About Image File Formats
- The most common types of image file formats are JPEG, PNG, and GIF. JPEGs are best for lossy image compression. PNGs are best for lossless digital images. GIFs are best for graphics, logos, and animations.
- When discussing image file formats, you’ll hear one of two things: Lossless compression and lossy compression. Lossless algorithms preserve a perfect copy of an uncompressed image while lossy algorithms preserve a smaller copy of that uncompressed image with certain inconspicuous aspects (such as wider color ranges or metadata) removed.
- You’ll typically see image file formats broken down into four groups: capturing, authoring, and, delivering, and creating. JPEG is a delivery type, whereas TIFF is an authoring type.
- Beyond these four groups, you have two major image types: pixel and vector. Vector image formats differ from pixel-based JPEG and TIFF files by displaying images in a geometric format — this allows them to be increased or decreased in display size without loss of quality.
- PDFs are considered both pixel and vector types, combining both format groups into one uniquely interactive format.
The JPEG gets its name from the Joint Photographic Experts Group. This large group is comprised of the members of two smaller ones: ITU-T Study Group 16 and ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29. The members of the Joint Photographic Experts Group have been meeting and working together semi-annually since 1983 at the earliest, though they did not come together to standardize the image file format now known as the JPEG until the year 1992.
This first project in 1983? Adding high-quality, detailed graphics to text terminals on the computers of the time. You might have heard these text terminals by a different name — perhaps text console, perhaps terminal — but one thing remains true about them regardless of the moniker.
In the early days of computers, these text terminals played a vital role in the function and performance of the technology. Because computer interfaces at the time were only designated to support text entry displays, there was eventually a need for images that began to arise in those early years. This underscores the important pioneering work of the ITU-T Study Group 16 and ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29.
By the time the JPEG group had officially formed in the late 1980s, there was a new task at hand: communicating via images over a computer network (i.e. picture messages.). Next on the agenda? The digital image compression format we now know as the JPEG.
As we said above, the group officially specified and standardized JPEG guidelines in 1992. You might occasionally see JPEG spelled without the E, abbreviated simply to JPG. This is actually the same thing as a JPEG. All early versions of Microsoft’s OS needed three-letter file formats. Thus, the JPG name was coined.
The Tag Image File Format — commonly referred to as either TIFF or TIF — differs from the JPEG in several key ways, right down to its very purpose. Instead of being used to compress images for easy storage and use, the TIFF file is used exclusively for storing raster graphics.
These images (or should we say graphics?) are most popular with publishers, graphic designers, artists, photographers, and others working with raster graphics on the regular. (Raster graphics are 2D images depicted in a rectangular grid made up of square pixels.)
TIFF files are most commonly used and shared via fax machines and scanners, word and image processors, desktop publishers, and other software and services pertaining to the above industries. Instead of being formed by a group or a coalition like the JPEG, the TIFF file was actually made by the Aldus Corporation (who we now know better as Adobe).
They created the file format for their desktop publishing software PageMaker (now InDesign). The other goal for the TIFF file format was to establish an agreed-upon standard for all the different desktop scanner vendors in the mid-80s.
Before TIFF, countless other proprietary file formats were used for raster graphics. The creation and establishment of TIFF helped alleviate the headache of artists, designers, and photographers needing to navigate and convert from format to format.
At its start, TIFF was merely a binary image format to match the capabilities of desktop scanners at the time. But, as time went on and the tech became more advanced, TIFF was able to become more advanced in turn. Today, TIFF is on Revision 6.0. TIFF published Revision 6.0 way back in 1992 and it has remained more or less unrevised since.
JPEG vs TIFF: Pros and Cons
|Pros of JPEG||Cons of JPEG|
|Very broadly compatible||Compression is lossy|
|Smaller image file sizes||No support for animation or transparency|
|Pros of TIFF||Cons of TIFF|
|Lossless compression||Larger image file sizes|
|Also quite compatible||Harder to send and receive|
JPEG vs TIFF: Which One Is Better?
In some debates, there are clear winners. In others, there are only winners depending on the kind of work you’re doing. This latter scenario is the case with the JPEG vs TIFF debate. Simply put, the superior format is always going to be the one designated for your specific task at hand.
If you’re sending a funny picture to a friend, you’ll want a JPEG. If you’re sending a batch of headshots to an editor to touch up, you’re going to want to use a TIFF file. This is ultimately what the JPEG vs TIFF debate boils down to: specific use cases with ideal formats for each one.