Key Points
- Super Mega Baseball 4 is an arcade-like game that allows you to play an exhibition match, season, elimination, or a pennant race in under 15-20 minutes.
- Out of the Park Baseball 24 is a baseball management game that offers real players and teams, but has a deep learning curve.
- BASEBALL STARS 2 is a retro-style game with graphics that feel like they belong on 8- or 16-bit consoles, and offers the opportunity to play up to 125 games in a single season.
- Baseball Mogul 2023 impresses with an incredible amount of historical baseball data, including draft data for 37,000 players going back to 1965.
- MLB Home Run Derby VR is an officially licensed game that allows you to compete in a home run derby in 30 real-life MLB ballparks using a VR-compatible headset and PC.
As “America’s Pastime,” baseball will always have a special place in the sporting world regardless of how popular football and soccer have grown. There is just something great about sitting in a ballpark on a clear summer day, eating a hot dog, and cheering on a team with your row.
Even as baseball has definitely gone through some changes over the years, it still keeps us coming back, at least for a few months of the year. For the other parts of the year when baseball season is over, the good news is that you can play baseball on your PC all year long.
If you’ve been on the hunt for the best baseball gaming experience your PC can handle, let’s take a look at the 5 best baseball games you can download today.
The Best Baseball Games for a PC Summary
| Rank | Name | Overview |
|---|---|---|
| #1 | Super Mega Baseball 4 | The arcade-like style of this game makes it fun to perform dizzying catches and monster hits. |
| #2 | Out of the Park Baseball 24 | Fantastic baseball management SIM with real-world players and teams |
| #3 | BASEBALL STARS 2 | Offers a retro feel that is right at home on a PC just as it did on the Nintendo Entertainment System |
| #4 | Baseball Mogul 2023 | An incredible amount of historical data for baseball going back as far as 1902 |
| #5 | MLB Home Run Derby VR | Officially licensed by MLB, the game takes place in all 30 major league stadiums. |
#1: Super Mega Baseball 4
- Over 200 former pro baseball players like Vladimir Guerrero, Johnny Damon, Ozzie Smith, and Jason Giambi
- Create your own roster or play on a team organized by era
- Steam PC online code
![Super Mega Baseball 4 Standard - Steam PC [Online Game Code]](https://history-computer.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/51pPhGMn7uL._SL500_.webp)
What Super Mega Baseball 4 lacks in realism, it more than makes up for in being a ton of overall fun.
This arcade-like game is baseball through and through and, in its fourth generation, finally introduces more than 200 larger-than-life versions of real-world players like Johnny Damon, Jason Giambi, and Ozzie Smith.
When it comes to gameplay, Super Mega Baseball 4 separates itself from the pack by utilizing an arcade-inspired style that allows you to play an exhibition match, season, elimination, or a pennant race. The game’s signature style also lets you play through a game in short order, so you can play a few games in under an hour. There is even a free agency opportunity to draft and acquire new players so you can continue to load your team with superstars.
Highlighting the fourth entry in the series, new visuals have been introduced for both the characters and stadiums as well as increased audio effects to make crowds feel even more realistic. New features aside, where Super Mega Baseball 4 really shines is its unique style that allows you to create your own squad of heavy hitters and take your team all the way to the championship.
The question isn’t how much you are going to enjoy Super Mega Baseball 4, but how many dingers you can hit in one sitting.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Arcade-like style is incredibly fun | Does not offer a sense of realism |
| Can quickly play one game in under 15-20 minutes | Player stats are not always relevant to hits |
#2: Out of the Park Baseball 24
If you want more of a true-life baseball experience, Out of the Park Baseball 24 offers a stand-out baseball strategy title.
The 24th version in the franchise, OOTPB 24 is a title that allows you to take ownership of your favorite professional baseball team and make all of the decisions. In this game, you are the manager and it’s your job to help manage everything from the front office to the dugout.
As the boss, you need to look at signing free agents as well as gaining a good draft position so you can find your team’s next big superstar. Plus, you have to navigate the world of baseball trades and develop top prospects in the minor leagues. Thankfully, Out of the Park Baseball 24 helps guide you through all of these processes with outstanding tutorials to make sure you have all of the info you need to become the next World Series champion.
Whether you are playing solo or participating against teams around the world, you can also build and customize your own fictional team. The level of depth available helps drive this title to the top of any best-of-baseball game for PC as it’s one of the best sports management games available period.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| The best baseball management game available | Requires plenty of patience to build a champion |
| Offers real players and teams | Has a deep learning curve |
#3: BASEBALL STARS 2
If you’re willing to go retro with your next baseball game on PC, BASEBALL STARS 2 is a fun title with a throwback feel.
Originally released as a baseball game for the Nintendo Entertainment System in 1992, a port for PC of BASEBALL STARS 2 would land in the Steam store in 2016. The highlight of this title is its retro look with graphics that feel as if they still belong on 8- or 16-bit consoles.
The single-player game focuses on your ability to play as one of 6 teams from around the world where you can take on opponents in a 15-game tournament. Switch gears to play against friends in a local co-op match and you can challenge them to a 9-inning battle with a split-screen view.
In addition, the updated release of BASEBALL STARS 2 added enhanced pitch controls and the ability to shift your player’s defensive position while your opponent is batting. As a bonus, the game also added the ability to see lead-offs while pitching, and you can now make substitutions for up to 6 pitchers and 4 bench players per game.
The heart of Baseball Stars 2 is the opportunity to play up to 125 games in a single season with league standings and stats for players with the most home runs and RBIs as well as wins and saves for pitchers.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Retro graphics take you back to the glory days of gaming | Arcade-style baseball experience isn’t true-to-life |
| Offers a lot of improvements over the original release | Does not include real names or players |
#4: Baseball Mogul 2023
If you’re looking for a more simplified baseball management title, Baseball Mogul 2022 is the way to go.
Right from the jump Baseball Mogul 2022 impresses thanks to historical schedules for every baseball season all the way from 1901 up to 2023. This includes postseason stats for all players from the first World Series in 1903 through 2022. Including these stats, you have more than 76,000 historical major and minor league players you can choose from, including draft data for 37,000 players going all the way back to 1965.
With all of this data available, Baseball Mogul 2022 throws you into the job of general manager of your favorite MLB team. It’s now your role to draft the right players and create a lineup that is capable of going deep into the postseason.
What’s more, you are not just the general manager as you dive right into games and enter play-by-play mode to make managerial calls in each game. If you want to call the right pitch, you can do exactly that or make the decision to try and stretch a double into a triple to go for the winning run.
Everything from its realistic simulation to detailed player editors helps make Baseball Mogul 2022 feel like a terrific management game and it can keep you involved for years to come.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| An incredible amount of historical baseball data | Too much data might be overwhelming for beginners |
| Offers you the ability to make in-game calls | Requires plenty of patience to get started |
#5: MLB Home Run Derby VR
If there is any type of baseball game that demands PC treatment, it’s MLB Home Run Derby VR.
There is just something magical about having the opportunity to compete in a home run derby. Millions of children around the world have at one point dreamed about this very opportunity and now you can live it in the comfort of your own home.
As a dedicated VR experience on PC, you will need a VR-compatible computer, but if you have one, you can try and swing for as many dingers as possible. The best part is that this game is officially licensed by MLB, so you have 30 true-to-life MLB ballparks to choose from in your attempt to win the home run derby again and again. You can even participate in the 2023 MLB All-Star game home run contest at the home of the Seattle Mariners.
Whether you are challenging your friends or going solo, you have to step up your game and hit as many dingers as possible. The game offers options for both right and left-handed swingers, with excellent visuals and game reviews reporting very few glitches, which makes for a smooth all-around experience on a compatible PC.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Officially licensed by MLB, it allows for 30 real-life stadiums | Requires a VR-compatible headset and PC |
| Play solo or with a friend | Only offers a home run derby mode |
©Vasyl Shulga/Shutterstock.com
Wrapping Up
Unfortunately, baseball games on the PC are a little scarce compared to consoles, which is disappointing news for gamers who use the PC as their main source of entertainment. While there are multiple versions of Super Mega Baseball, there hasn’t been a real-world baseball game like R.B.I. Baseball games released in the last few years for the PC. Instead, developers have dedicated their time to video game consoles where sales are stronger. Thankfully, these 5 games represent some excellent ways to still enjoy America’s pastime on a PC without the need to worry about finding a parking space near a stadium.
The image featured at the top of this post is ©Andrey Yurlov/Shutterstock.com.
