© Tero Vesalainen / Shutterstock.com

Two-factor authentication is becoming increasingly important for online security, and there are many options available for users to choose from. Authy and Google Authenticator are two of the most popular options, and both offer a range of features to help users secure their online accounts.

Authy and Google Authenticator work by providing an additional layer of security to an account, in addition to a password. This second layer is usually a code that is generated by the app and must be entered in addition to the password in order to access the account.

Both Authy and Google Authenticator offer a range of features and benefits, making them a great choice for anyone looking to secure their online accounts.

Authy vs. Google Authenticator: Side-by-Side Comparison

CategoryAuthyGoogle Authenticator
Platform SupportAvailable on multiple platforms such as iOS, Android, Mac, Windows, and the webLimited to only Android and iOS
Cloud BackupOffers cloud backup of your 2FA tokensDoes not offer cloud backup of your 2FA tokens
Multiple DevicesAllows you to use the same account on multiple devicesRequires a separate installation and setup for each device
User InterfaceHas a more user-friendly interface with a clear display of your 2FA tokens and the ability to add multiple accountsHas a simple, minimalistic interface
Push NotificationsSupports push notifications for authentication requestsDoes not support push notifications for authentication requests
Security Capabilities?YesYes
Works Offline?YesYes

Authy vs. Google Authenticator: What’s the Difference?

With the increasing need for added security measures in our digital lives, two-factor authentication has become a widely used method to provide an extra layer of protection. Two of the most popular tools for this purpose are Authy and Google Authenticator, but many are left wondering, what’s the difference between them?

Let’s break it down below.

Multi-Device Platform Support

Authy is a multi-device platform, which means that users can use the same account across multiple devices, including smartphones, tablets, and computers. This makes it easier for users to switch devices and access their accounts without having to go through the hassle of resetting authentication codes.

On the other hand, Google Authenticator is a single-device platform and is limited to the device it was set up on. If a user loses access to their device or switches to a new one, they must reset their authentication codes on the new device. This can be inconvenient for users who use multiple devices and frequently switch between them.

Supported Authentication

Authy provides a versatile form of two-factor authentication by offering OTP (One-Time Password) via SMS or voice call and TOTP (Time-based One-Time Password) generated within the app itself. Users receive push notifications when attempting to access a registered site, adding another layer of security.

Google Authenticator does not offer OTP through SMS or voice call, but instead generates both TOTP and HOTP (HMAC-based One-Time Password) within the app. This creates a more streamlined approach to two-factor authentication but may not be as convenient for users who prefer receiving OTP through other methods.

google authenticator
Google Authenticator only uses a one-time password through the app instead of via SMS or phone call.

©Sharaf Maksumov/Shutterstock.com

Backups and Synchronization

Authy provides the added convenience of automatic synchronization among approved devices. A user’s two-factor authentication updates and transfers automatically if they lose their device or switch to a new one, without manual intervention.

In contrast, Google Authenticator only offers a manual transfer of accounts from one device to another. This means that if a user switches devices, they will need to manually transfer their accounts and two-factor authentication information, which could be time-consuming and potentially lead to lost data.

Security Capabilities

Authy is a reliable and secure authenticator app that provides users with enhanced security features to protect their sensitive information. The application employs a combination of PIN and biometric authentication for granting access to the tokens generated. This added security feature prevents unauthorized individuals from accessing your information and compromising your online presence.

Additionally, Authy uses encryption for all backups stored securely in the cloud, providing protection against cyber-attacks. In cases of device loss, the cloud-based backups make it convenient for users to retrieve their credentials from another device.

Google Authenticator is another popular option for those seeking an authenticator app. While it offers similar security features, such as two-factor authentication and time-based tokens, it lacks the added layer of protection offered by Authy. However, Google Authenticator remains popular due to its ease of use and compatibility with a wide range of websites and services.

Ultimately, the decision between Authy and Google Authenticator comes down to personal preference and the level of security desired. Both apps provide users with a secure way to manage their online accounts and protect their sensitive information.

Supported Platform

Authy is available on a variety of platforms, including Android, iOS, macOS, Windows, Linux, and the Apple Watch. This allows users to use Authy on their chosen device, regardless of operating system. This makes it a convenient choice for those who need 2FA on multiple devices.

Google Authenticator is limited to Android and iOS devices. This means that users who are on other platforms, such as Windows or macOS, will not be able to use Google Authenticator. This can be a significant limitation for those who need 2FA on multiple devices.

The Evolution of Authy

Launched in 2011, Authy has undergone several significant changes to enhance its features and user experience.

Initially, Authy was designed to run as a browser extension, providing 2FA codes for websites that supported it. Over time, the app expanded its offerings to include mobile apps for iOS and Android and a desktop app. This allowed users to receive 2FA codes on any device, even when away from their computer.

In 2015, Authy introduced multi-device support, enabling users to link multiple devices to their account and receive 2FA codes on any of them. This made it easier for users to switch between devices and maintain access to their protected accounts.

In 2016, Authy added a “One Touch” feature that enables users to approve or deny login requests with a single tap on their mobile device. This streamlined the authentication process and reduced the time required to approve a login request.

In 2018, Authy was acquired by Twilio, a cloud communications platform, and became part of the Twilio Authy product suite. With this acquisition, Authy gained access to Twilio’s robust infrastructure and resources, allowing it to continue expanding its offerings.

Millions of users today employ Authy to support a diverse array of websites and apps, such as Gmail, Dropbox, and Facebook. The app evolves constantly, adding new features and improvements regularly to ensure users receive the most secure and user-friendly two-factor authentication experience.

authy two factor authentication 2fa
Authy makes use of a “One Touch” feature where the user can approve or deny a login request in just a single tap.

©ECO LENS/Shutterstock.com

History of Google Authenticator

Google first introduced the app in 2010 as a way to make online transactions more secure and protect users from unauthorized access.

Before the introduction of Google Authenticator, 2FA was primarily implemented through SMS codes. However, SMS codes can be vulnerable to hacking, making it easier for cybercriminals to gain access to users’ accounts. Google Authenticator was created as a solution to this problem.

Google Authenticator generates time-based one-time passwords (TOTPs) which are unique to each user and cannot be reused. This makes it more secure compared to SMS codes, as it eliminates the possibility of hackers intercepting the code and using it to access the user’s account.

Authy vs. Google Authenticator: 6 Must-Know Facts

  • Authy supports multi-device synchronization, while Google Authenticator is limited to a single device.
  • Authy has a built-in backup and restore feature, making it easier to recover access to accounts if a phone is lost or damaged.
  • Authy allows users to add and manage multiple accounts, while Google Authenticator only supports one account at a time.
  • Authy offers a cloud-based solution, which allows for secure and seamless integration with other devices.
  • Authy allows users to access their accounts through a web-based interface, while Google Authenticator is limited to a mobile app.
  • Google Authenticator is open-source, while Authy is a proprietary software.

Authy vs. Google Authenticator: Which One is Better?

The winner in the Authy versus Google Authenticator debate is Authy.

While both Authy and Google Authenticator are popular two-factor authentication (2FA) solutions, Authy has a number of features that make it a better choice for most users.

First and foremost, Authy is much more user-friendly than Google Authenticator. Its interface is straightforward and easy to use, with clear instructions on how to set up 2FA for your various accounts. It also has a cloud-based system that allows you to access your 2FA codes from any device, so you don’t have to worry about losing access to your accounts if you lose your phone.

In addition, Authy also has several security features that make it a better choice for those concerned about the safety of their 2FA codes. For example, it uses encryption to protect your 2FA codes and also offers the ability to backup your 2FA codes in case you lose access to your device.

Another advantage of Authy is that it is more versatile than Google Authenticator. It supports a wider range of accounts and services, making it easier for users to use. Furthermore, Authy offers a number of customization options, allowing you to tailor the app to your specific needs.

Finally, Authy is more reliable than Google Authenticator. It is less likely to experience outages or other issues that could prevent you from accessing your 2FA codes. Additionally, Authy has a more robust support system, with helpful resources and knowledgeable staff available to assist you if you have any questions or concerns.

Authy vs. Google Authenticator: Features, Differences, and More FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) 

What are the key features of Authy and Google Authenticator?

Authy offers several key features, such as automatic backup and synchronization of 2FA codes across multiple devices, the ability to use 2FA codes offline, and the ability to store encrypted passwords. Google Authenticator, on the other hand, offers a simple and straightforward way to set up 2FA, with a focus on security and ease of use.

What are the security features of Authy and Google Authenticator?

Both Authy and Google Authenticator use encryption to keep 2FA codes secure. However, Authy uses a stronger encryption algorithm and offers additional security features such as automatic backups and password management. Google Authenticator, on the other hand, relies on the security of the user’s device to keep 2FA codes safe.

How easy is it to set up 2FA with Authy and Google Authenticator?

Setting up 2FA with Authy and Google Authenticator is straightforward and easy. Both apps offer step-by-step instructions for setting up 2FA, and the process is usually completed in just a few minutes.

How does Authy and Google Authenticator work?

Both Authy and Google Authenticator work by generating a unique code that is required in addition to a password to access an online account. When users try logging into an account, they will be prompted to enter the code from their 2FA app.

About the Author

More from History-Computer

  • Android Police Available here: https://www.androidpolice.com/how-to-use-google-authenticator-authy-2fa-secure-accounts/#:~:text=Google%20Authenticator%20only%20stores%20codes,device%20and%20access%20your%20codes.
  • Tech Republic Available here: https://www.techrepublic.com/article/authy-vs-google-authenticator/
  • Authy Available here: https://authy.com/blog/authy-vs-google-authenticator/
  • Technology Advice Available here: https://technologyadvice.com/blog/information-technology/authy-vs-google-authenticator/
  • Password Managers Available here: https://password-managers.bestreviews.net/google-authenticator-vs-authy-which-is-the-best-2fa-app/